2207.05964
Co-evolution of Vaccination Behavior and Perceived Vaccination Risk can lead to a Stag-Hunt like Game
Yuan Liu, Bin Wu
correctmedium confidence
- Category
- Not specified
- Journal tier
- Specialist/Solid
- Processed
- Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM
- arXiv Links
- Abstract ↗PDF ↗
Audit review
The paper derives the same ODE system, fixed points, existence conditions, and stability classification as the candidate solution. In particular: (i) the model equations and piecewise infection risk f(x) are identical to Eq. (7) in the paper, with V(n)=V_L+n(V_H−V_L) and ṅ=n(1−n)[(1+θ)−(2+θ)x] ; (ii) the seven fixed points and their existence conditions are listed exactly as in Appendix B ; (iii) the interior equilibrium exists for (2+θ)C/(C−V_L) < R0 < (2+θ)C/(C−V_H) and is a saddle (det J<0), while boundary equilibria (1) and (2) are stable when R0>(2+θ)C/(C−V_L) and R0<(2+θ)C/(C−V_H), respectively; only corner (5) can be stable, matching the candidate’s Jacobian-based classification and the paper’s case-by-case summary . The paper also states that when R0 lies between the two thresholds, the dynamics is stag-hunt-like with two stable boundary equilibria separated by an interior saddle, in agreement with the candidate’s Part C . Minor typographical sign errors in the paper’s printed formulas for n* and some Jacobian entries do not affect the stated stability classification and regime decomposition; the candidate solution notes and corrects these implicitly by re-deriving the conditions from first principles.
Referee report (LaTeX)
\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions
\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid
\textbf{Justification:}
The manuscript develops a transparent two-dimensional co-evolutionary model of vaccination behavior and perceived risk, derives complete fixed-point existence and stability conditions, and highlights a robust stag-hunt-like window with two stable boundary regimes separated by an interior saddle. The analysis is correct and the qualitative insights are well motivated. However, several algebraic expressions (the interior n* and certain Jacobian entries) contain sign typos that, while not affecting the final classification, should be corrected. Clarifying the piecewise branch of f(x) at the interior equilibrium and streamlining the stability proofs (e.g., via triangular Jacobians on the edges) would further improve readability.