Back to search
2111.06651

SRB MEASURES FOR C∞ SURFACE DIFFEOMORPHISMS

David Burguet

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Top Field-Leading
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper’s Main Theorem (countably many ergodic SRB measures covering the positive Lyapunov set and describing level sets) is explicitly stated and proved for C^\infty surface diffeomorphisms via an entropic construction using hyperbolic times, F\"olner sequences, entropy estimates, and absolute continuity of stable foliations. The manuscript also stresses that the C^\infty hypothesis is essential and formulates only a conjecture (not a theorem) for finite smoothness with the R(f)/r threshold. The candidate solution hinges on a nonexistent “Burguet’s C^r theorem” and builds the C^\infty result by taking r\to\infty, which contradicts the paper’s own statement that the C^r analog is conjectural (and that the C^\infty theorem is false in finite smoothness without an R(f)/r threshold). The model’s auxiliary appeal to Sarig’s symbolic coding and equilibrium states is not used in the paper’s proof and does not repair the central gap.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} top field-leading

\textbf{Justification:}

The manuscript solves, in the C\^∞ surface setting, a central existence-and-structure problem for SRB measures under a natural positive-Lyapunov hypothesis, and does so by a conceptually clean and versatile entropic approach built from hyperbolic times and Fölner sequences. The proof culminates in a covering argument via absolute continuity of stable foliations and includes a precise level-set description of the maximal exponent. The necessity of C\^∞ is highlighted, and a plausible C\^r conjecture is recorded. Some expository tweaks would further improve readability, but the contribution is both correct and significant.