Back to search
2106.08374

Warning Signs for Non-Markovian Bifurcations: Color Blindness and Scaling Laws

Christian Kuehn, Kerstin Lux, Alexandra Neamţu

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM

Audit review

The paper proves that along the attracting branch of the slow manifold the adiabatic variance V∞(y) diverges with universal exponents that depend on the bifurcation normal form and the noise type: white noise yields exponents (−1, −1, −1/2), colored OU noise shows no divergence (0, 0, 0), and α-regular Volterra noises (including fBM and Rosenblatt with H = α + 1/2) yield exponents (−2H, −2H, −H). These statements, derived via linearization and an adiabatic limit for a nonlocal variance equation, are explicit in the paper’s formulas (normal-form derivatives a(y): y, y, −2√−y; white-noise scaling; OU “color blindness”; α-regular and fBM/Rosenblatt scalings and Table 1) . The candidate solution independently linearizes around the attracting manifold and computes the stationary variances of the resulting linear filters: OU for white noise; a 2×2 OU Lyapunov equation for colored noise; and a Volterra/Young-integral representation for α-regular drivers. It reproduces all exponents and constants specialized to fBM/Rosenblatt (V∞ = σ² H Γ(2H)/|a(y)|^{2H}), exactly matching the paper. The only minor discrepancy is an intermediate constant for generic α-regular noise (a factor α(2α+1) versus the paper’s cαΓ(2α)), which does not affect exponents and reduces to the same H Γ(2H) constant under the standard fBM/Rosenblatt normalization. Overall, proofs differ in technique but agree on results.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The paper is technically sound and provides an important clarification of when classical variance-based early-warning signals fail or change under non-Markovian noise. The main results are correct, succinctly derived, and supported by numerics. Minor clarifications regarding normalization constants in the Volterra framework would further improve accessibility without altering the main conclusions.