2104.01116
A Fractal Eigenvector
Neil J. Calkin, Eunice Y. S. Chan, Robert M. Corless, David J. Jeffrey, Piers W. Lawrence
correcthigh confidence
- Category
- Not specified
- Journal tier
- Top Generalist
- Processed
- Sep 28, 2025, 12:56 AM
- arXiv Links
- Abstract ↗PDF ↗
Audit review
The paper defines Mn via the 3×3 block recursion and derives the polynomial-eigenvector recursion xn+1(ρ) = [ρ Cn(ρ) xn(ρ); Cn(ρ); xn(ρ)], then shows by direct block substitution that Cn(ρ)e1 + Mn xn(ρ) = ρ xn(ρ) at ρ = ρn+1 and that the last entry is 1, i.e., essentially (Mn − ρ I) xn(ρ) = −Cn(ρ) e1, with Cn+1(ρ) = ρ Cn(ρ)^2 − 1 ensuring (Mn+1 − ρ I) xn+1(ρ) = −Cn+1(ρ) e1 and hence eigenvectorhood when Cn+1(ρ)=0 (equations (4), (10)–(14), (11) in the paper) . The candidate solution reproduces the same construction and identities, proving them for all real ρ by induction and then specializing to ρn+1, which matches the paper’s approach and conclusions.
Referee report (LaTeX)
\textbf{Recommendation:} no revision
\textbf{Journal Tier:} top generalist
\textbf{Justification:}
The submission faithfully reproduces the paper’s block-recursive eigenvector construction and associated polynomial identity, with a clean induction that holds for all real ρ before specializing to eigenvalues. The logic aligns line-by-line with the published argument, and all identities are verified. The presentation is crisp and self-contained once the recursions are specified.