Back to search
2011.12257

Safely Learning Dynamical Systems from Short Trajectories

Amir Ali Ahmadi, Abraar Chaudhry, Vikas Sindhwani, Stephen Tu

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:55 AM

Audit review

The paper’s Theorem 1 states that the feasible set of the robust problem (7) is exactly the projection (onto x) of the LP (8), and it proves this by dualizing the inner LP over A (equations (9)–(10)), invoking strong duality, and using weak/strong duality to show equivalence of feasible sets and equality of optimal values. The candidate solution reproduces the same construction: it expresses h_i^T A x as a Frobenius inner product, forms the Lagrangian, derives the same dual feasibility identity x h_i^T = Σ_k x_k η_k^{(i)T} + Σ_j μ_j^{(i)} V_j^T, and uses weak/strong duality to prove projection equivalence and value equality. This matches the paper’s argument essentially step-by-step, with slightly more derivational detail and an explicit note that U_m is nonempty (which holds in the paper’s setting since A? ∈ U_k by construction). Hence both are correct and substantially the same proof. See Theorem 1 and its proof (stating (7)–(8) and the dualization via (9)–(10)) in the paper ; the problem setup (U0, S, Uk, and (7)) appears in Section 3.1 .

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The theorem and its proof are technically sound and well aligned with standard LP duality. The result is essential to the paper’s tractable formulation of one-step safe learning and integrates well with the algorithmic framework. Minor clarifications on assumptions (nonemptiness of Uk, dual attainment) would further improve readability.