Back to search
2011.07843

Stochastic modification of Newtonian dynamics and Induced potential - application to spiral galaxies and the dark potential

Jacky Cresson, Laurent Nottale, Thierry Lehner

correctmedium confidence
Category
math.DS
Journal tier
Specialist/Solid
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:55 AM

Audit review

The paper proves the stochastic Hamilton–Jacobi equation for the complex action A by inserting the gradient-velocity representation D_μX_t = (1/m)∇A into the differential stochastic Newton equation and applying the chain rule for D_μ, obtaining ∇[∂_tA + (1/(2m))|∇A|^2 + iμ(σ^2/2)ΔA] = −∇U and hence ∂_tA + (1/(2m))|∇A|^2 + iμ(σ^2/2)ΔA = −U (Theorem 6) . The candidate solution follows the same steps, explicitly computing the transport term (∇A·∇)∇A = (1/2)∇|∇A|^2/m and noting the possible additive function of time c(t), then fixing the time-gauge—an innocuous refinement not made explicit in the paper. The action representation used (V = ∇A/m) is exactly Lemma 5 in the paper , and the chain-rule step mirrors equation (76) in the proof of Theorem 6 . Overall, both arguments are correct and essentially identical; the model adds a minor clarification (time-gauge).

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} specialist/solid

\textbf{Justification:}

The derivation of the stochastic Hamilton–Jacobi equation within the differential stochastic Newton framework is correct and closely follows standard Nelson-calculus machinery. The exposition is generally clear, and the conceptual link to complex action is useful. Minor improvements would be to state the time-gauge freedom of A explicitly and to mention regularity/density assumptions used when passing from pathwise identities to PDEs.