Back to search
2006.15453

The effect of heterogeneity on hypergraph contagion models

Nicholas W. Landry, Juan G. Restrepo

correctmedium confidence
Category
Not specified
Journal tier
Strong Field
Processed
Sep 28, 2025, 12:55 AM

Audit review

The paper derives, for the degree-correlated (collective) case, the critical triangle infectivity β_c3/γ = ⟨k^3⟩⟨k⟩^2/⟨k^2⟩^3 by analyzing h(V,β2) near V=0 and using the sign of ∂h/∂V at β2=β_c2 (its Eq. (35)), and for the uncorrelated case it expands to obtain h(V,β_c2) = (a0+a1 V + a2 V^2) V^2 with explicit a0,a1,a2 and a piecewise onset criterion: saddle-node via a1^2−4 a0 a2=0 with 0≤−a1/(2a2)≤1 and a2<0, or else transcritical at a0=0 giving β_c3 = γ⟨k^3⟩/⟨k⟩^4 (Eqs. (38)–(42)) . The candidate solution reproduces exactly these steps and thresholds, including the discriminant and admissibility conditions for the uncorrelated case and the transcritical fallback at V=0, with matching moment dependence and normal-form reasoning. Hence both are correct and essentially the same proof route.

Referee report (LaTeX)

\textbf{Recommendation:} minor revisions

\textbf{Journal Tier:} strong field

\textbf{Justification:}

The results and methods in the paper align directly with the candidate solution: the onset thresholds β\_c3 for both correlated and uncorrelated cases, the discriminant-based saddle-node condition with admissibility constraints, and the transcritical fallback at V=0 are all consistent and well supported by expansions of the mean-field equations. Numerical evidence corroborates the analytical predictions. Minor clarifications on expansion assumptions and a potential typographic denominator in a0 would further improve readability without affecting correctness.